Agitation & Activism: The Latest Fad

How India's young liberals are turning protests into content.
There is a particular kind of photograph that has defined Indian dissent over the decade. Picture of neo-liberal activists Sonam Wangchuk, propped on a bed, with a placard around announcing the so-called fast-until-death agenda.
This is not activism. It is content, wearing activism's clothes.
For a generation raised inside the attention economy, it was perhaps inevitable that protest would be reshaped by the incentives of the platforms it lives on. But something has been lost in the translation from one moment to the next. The agitations of an earlier India, the JP movement, the anti-Mandal protests, even the Anna Hazare mobilisation of 2011, were sustained by organisational discipline: unions, student federations, sympathetic newspapers willing to run the story on day forty, not just day one.
What sustains today's protest is engagement, a metric that rewards novelty and punishes duration. A cause that cannot be refreshed with a new visual every 48 hours simply falls out of the feed, and out of existence.
The teenagers and young liberals showing up to these moments are not, in the main, insincere. That is precisely the problem. Sincerity without structure produces spectacle, not pressure. Genuine political agitation has always required something these participants rarely offer: repeated, unglamorous presence — the door-knocking, the pamphleteering, the willingness to stand in a square on a Tuesday when no one is watching. Instagram rewards the opposite instinct. It rewards being seen once, well.
This is why so many of these movements dissolve the moment the algorithm moves on. Participation, for many, was never an ideological commitment but a social one — a way of signaling belonging to a particular class of person: educated, English-speaking, aesthetically fluent in the visual grammar of Western progressivism. The signaling requires no theory of change, no reading of the specific law or policy in question, no plan for what happens after the story disappears. It requires only the correct expression, correctly lit.
Contrast this with the durability of India's more consequential recent mobilizations — the farmers' protests of 2020-21 chief among them — which succeeded in part because they were unglamorous, prolonged, and rooted in material stakes that did not depend on continuous online affirmation to sustain themselves. Farmers camped at Delhi's borders for over a year. There was no equivalent enthusiasm among the urban teenage set for a movement that offered mud, cold, and monotony instead of a shareable frame.
None of this is unique to India — the critique of "slacktivism" has trailed social media since the Arab Spring. But it lands with particular force in a country where genuine, costly dissent has historically demanded so much more than a caption. Until participation in agitation once again requires something the algorithm cannot reward — sacrifice, repetition, organisation — it will remain what it has largely become: a fad mistaken, by its own participants, for a conviction.



Comments